I have found this in my makeup storage and have never opened it and thought that this is a good chance to try it. I have then noticed that this eyeliner is now discontinued but you can still purchase it on eBay if you want to try it or stock up.
Has a sponge tip for easy control which is a great eyeliner for eyeliner novices. The sponge isn’t flimsy therefore you are able to control the thickness of the eyeliner. I was surprised at how black this was. Probably the very few drugstore eyeliners that were this black. It gave a nice glossy finish. When applying, it didn’t bleed and had dried quickly. This was long lasting and had lasted on my eyelid for the majority of the day. I have noticed that if it does slightly touch and wetness, it will disappear. I yawn quite a bit and get watery. It’s easy to get it out of your bag and reapply without a fuss.
If this was waterproof, it’d be perfect then I’d repurchase it. It’s a shame that it is discontinued. L’Oreal does still have their original Super Liner (gold packaging) that can be bought in stores.